By Christie Keith
It came across one of my dog lists, a little rant about the breeder from whom Joe Biden got his German Shepherd puppy, and how Biden had made a bad choice.The person who posted it meant well. Our readers have commented about this subject on Pet Connection before. It’s not outside the realm of possibility that I might have written something like it if this had taken place two or three years ago. But no more.
Joe Biden reached out to an experienced law enforcement canine handler to help him find a German Shepherd puppy. He in turn researched local breeders, looking for someone who specialized in breeding family pets rather than working dogs. It’s not like he picked up a dog from out in front of the local flea market. And yet this breeder turned out to be one most of us wouldn’t have recommended, and probably could have told fairly easily wasn’t the best choice.
If the Vice President-elect of the United States and a U.S .Senator, who is a previous German Shepherd owner to boot, with the services of a top law enforcement German Shepherd handler, cannot successfully find a good family dog from a responsible breeder … it’s too hard, folks.
We’ve let the quest for a good breeder and a good family pet become an insider’s game, where you have to be able to decipher codes, know the secret handshake, and keep Sauron from finding the freaking ring before you get a nice puppy. And even then, half the dog fancy and the entire rescue community will be ready to jump down your throat for all the ten thousand ways you could have done it better.
And that’s not good for dogs. Because there are plenty of people who could give dogs good, loving homes out there who are going to outlets that sell puppies from high volume commercial breeders. They’re buying puppies meant to live as members of their families but have never in their short lives been a part of one, because they’re being raised like livestock.
Most of those people are not doing it because they’re stupid or careless or impatient; most of them are doing it because the alternatives are invisible to them.
One reason breeders are so hard to find is pretty easy to figure out: fear. Fear of aggressive anti-breeding activists in their local animal control and shelter. Fear of mandatory spay/neuter laws. Fear of breed bans, limit laws, and even sting operations. This whole bizarre idea that we should register and license people who breed a litter or two a year or less… why? It’s no more a business than an occasional garage sale is, and all it does is create a database of people who have intact animals. In the current climate, can anyone really fail to understand why no one who breeds or shows is likely to go along with that?
But that’s not the only reason. Breeders have also allowed themselves to be made to feel ashamed of breeding dogs, of being devoted to their breeds. They’ve been convinced that they have to rationalize and explain what they do, have to point out they do rescue and donate to shelters and really care about dogs in order to… what? Justify bringing a carefully bred puppy into the world and placing him or her into a loving home?
The “don’t breed and buy while shelter dogs die” mantra was way, way too effective, but that doesn’t make it true. Its premise is that there’s a connection between the puppies of small, careful, home-based breeders and the deaths of dogs in shelters. But if we have learned anything in this post-”Redemption” era it’s that dogs die in shelters not because of “irresponsible pet owners” or “greedy breeders” but because of the shelters’ own policies and actions.
This repressive, white-lipped scorn of breeders springs from exactly the same ideology that gives us rescue groups and shelters that can barely find a home they consider good enough to adopt a pet to. Which are usually run by the exact same people who mourn and lament and rend their garments about how all the irresponsible bad pet owners are the ones making them kill all these poor dogs and cats, and swearing we cannot adopt our way out of “pet overpopulation,” and wielding shelter kill statistics like a club to punish pet owners who don’t treat their animals in exactly the way they’d like them to.
The whole thing is just a big huge heap of propaganda. Owning dogs is not a zero sum game. People often have dogs from breeders and shelters or rescue groups at the same time. Dogs are like potato chips to most of us, and once we have one, wherever we get her, we’re likely to get another. If we want to increase the number of shelter adoptions — and I know I do — we’d have a lot more luck doing that if we promoted shelter dogs instead of telling home-based breeders they’re bad and wrong for doing what dog lovers have done for thousands of years, breed their dogs.
How is it good for the future of dogs if those breeders who should be the source of the happiest, healthiest family companions are instead driven into hiding by a combination of punitive regulation and shame? All the breeders I know support and volunteer for and refer people to their breed rescue; what will happen to the good they do if they’re driven so deep underground no one can find them?
And then, what will be left except the very USDA-approved high volume commercial breeders we decry?
Maybe if the “responsible breeders” weren’t hiding, Joe Biden could have found one of them. After all, people who breed dogs are just like everyone else. Some are wonderful, some suck. Some are good to their dogs, honest and careful; some are greedy and mean. It is, amazingly, the exact same ratio of good to bad as you’ll find among shelter directors, airline pilots, and pet writers.
Finding the good ones is truly no more or less difficult than finding a good hairdresser, doctor, dentist, or person to plan your wedding. You don’t need a secret decoder ring. Gollum will not help nor betray you. You might get ripped off — it happens. But it’s not a mystery. The exact same set of skills that allow you to find a good day care center, or the lack of skills that gets you suckered at the car repair shop, will be in play when you look for a dog breeder.
If the playing field were leveled, and the propaganda, fear, and shame taken out of the picture, it would increase, not decrease, the number of good vs. bad breeders. Those small, home-based breeders we’ve condemned with the term “backyard breeder” and equated with puppy mills (talk about propaganda) would be forced to improve their practices if they had to compete with the kind of breeder we all want to get a puppy from: ethical, honest, caring, knowledgeable about genetic and temperament issues in her breed and lines, committed to improving and preserving her breed, providing a lifetime safety net for the puppy in case things don’t work out.
But those are the very ones hiding in the shadows. I think it’s time to come out.







The German Shorthaired Pointer
Personality







